In general, if you disagree with a judge's ruling or remedy, you can appeal in accordance with section 2.9 of the Magic Tournament Rules: From that description it seems likely that they simply assumed that the opponent was correct, or knew what they were talking about. The fact that the judge took their cue from the opponent when determining the remedy makes this additionally questionable. If the action was casting a spell, the spell returns to the zone it came from. If a player takes an illegal action or starts to take an action but can’t legally complete it, the entire action is reversed and any payments already made are canceled. It is not inconceivable that a judge could interpret these instructions as allowing them to do a backup to after you announced the spell and before you chose targets, but that would be a stretch, and essentially inconsistent with rule 721.1: The GRV remedy section then further says that partial remedies can then be applied to only a specific set of situations, none of which match the situation in question. Every action must be reversed no parts of the sequence should be omitted or reordered. To perform a backup, each individual action since the point of the error is reversed, starting with the most recent ones and working backwards. The remedy section for that item says that a judge should first consider a simple backup. The situation in question looks like a "Game Play Error - Game Rule Violation". If you activate or trigger the ability of an artifact, creature, or enchantment, such as the activated ability of ] or the triggered ability of ], you can't choose the hexproof creature as the target for that ability.The guide for judges handling rules infractions is called the Infraction Procedure Guide. One example of a card that can do this is the last ability of ]. You can still attach that aura to a hexproof creature if an effect causes you to put ] onto the battlefield. When you cast an aura with enchant creature, it doesn't say target on the card, but it does target a creature, thus you couldn't cast enchant ] on a hexproof commander. If you cast a Creature which triggers an ability that targets, such as ], it can not target your opponents creature. Hexproof from is "Cardname can't be the target of spells or abilities whose source is that your opponents control." What that means is if you have to choose targets for a spell or ability with an artifact, creature, or enchantment source, you can't choose your opponents hexproof thing. r/magicTCG is not produced, endorsed, supported by, or affiliated with Wizards of the Coast. Magic: The Gathering, including card images, symbols, and text, is © Wizards of the Coast, LLC, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. The Lost Caverns of Ixalan November 2023.The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth June 23, 2023.March of the Machine: The Aftermath May 12, 2023. The bot will automatically post a comment in reply, with links for that card.įree discussion thread every weekend Upcoming Set Releases Name in your post or comment and put it in double brackets, like this: Images, up-to-date text, rulings, and more. We have a card-information bot in this subreddit which can fetch How to identify what set a card is from.Roundup of other Magic-related subreddits and sites.Playing Magic during the coronavirus pandemic.No posts that are just pictures of cards.Buy/sell/trade in the consolidated thread.No sexually explicit content or violence/disturbing imagery.The rules listed in this sidebar are a brief summary meant to give youĪ general idea of our subreddit rules.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |